Credo
16 Nov 2026
The inevitability of war
“War is like love, it always finds a way.” – Bertolt Brecht
We live in a broken world, where war is an tragic constant. Some conflicts make global headlines,like the USA-Iran war, the Russia-Ukraine war, or the Israel-Hamas war. Others feuds are less prominent, such as the Myanmar civil war, the Sudan civil war, the Afghanistan-Pakistan skirmishes,the Ethiopia-Eritrea war… Are we 21st-century humans really that much more enlightened and civilised than our medieval or ancient predecessors? Through all these centuries, war remains with us still.
Peacemaking in the Now-and-Not-Yet
“Blessed are the peacemakers, for they will be called children of God.”- Matthew 5.9
Into this timeless tragedy of war, the timeless gospel speaks. As followers of the Prince of Peace(Isaiah 9.6), we are called to live counter-culturally, to make peace when the world would make war.
As Christians, we look for that day when, as the hymn declares, “from pole to pole, that wars may cease, and all be prayer and praise”. In God’s New Creation, this will be our lived reality.
Yet for now, the Kingdom of God is both Now-and-Not-Yet. The Kingdom is truly present and active,but not yet fully realised or consummated. The power of the Risen Christ is now present to save, heal, and deliver; yet no ideal utopia can exist in this age where creation remains tainted by sin, death, and decay.
Pertinently, in the Now-and-Not-Yet, pacifism is perhaps a symptom of an over-realised eschatology – that is, mistakenly viewing the Kingdom as already fully present.
Pacifism, in its maximalist sense, is a total rejection of violence whatever the circumstance. Such absolute disavowal of physical force certainly stems from good, even Biblical intentions. Pacifism takes seriously the call of Christians to be peacemakers, to “turn the other cheek” (Matthew 5.39). Pacifism correctly recognises that there are many ways to resolve conflicts – whether at individual, community, societal, or international levels – without resorting to violence.
Still, we live in the Now-and-Not-Yet, where one neighbour can and will enact violence upon another neighbour of ours. How, in such circumstances, do we “love our neighbour(s)” and be peacemakers?
There are no easy answers.
But most of us would agree that if all other conflict-resolution options have been tried and failed, we would not simply abandon a neighbour to suffer violence at the hand of another. Rather, we would help defend our vulnerable neighbour against our aggressive neighbour, utilising limited force as necessary.
To be fair, some pacifist thinkers acknowledge this problem with universal and maximal pacifism, resulting in varieties of pacifism (or pacific-ism) which grudgingly recognise the use of force in certain circumstances or by certain persons. This, then, comes closer to Just War thinking.
How is Just War justified?
“The first casualty of war is truth.” – attributed to US Senator Hiram Johnson
Just War has been, very broadly speaking, the default position of most of the organised Church for centuries. Just War thinking delineates the circumstances in which making war is considered just – i.e., righteous, reasonable, and fair.
The two major dimensions of Just War are rightness in going to war (Latin: jus ad bellum) and rightness in the conduct of war (jus in bello). These rightness criteria include:
a) Right reasons (Just cause). Fundamentally, war should not be an initiation of aggression, but a response to it.
b) Right societal institution (Legitimate Authority). Idiosyncratic or vigilante acts of aggression are rejected.
c) Right prior attempts (Last resort). All other non-violent attempts at resolving conflict or securing others’ needs should be exhausted before utilising force.
d) Right calibration of actions (Probability of Success, Proportionality, Discrimination of Participants). Since violent actions are not for violence’s sake but as means to a goal (e.g. defending the vulnerable), violent actions should cease when the goal is reached. The degree of violence dealt should not be of disproportionate magnitude to the desired goal. This also includes distinguishing between combatants and non-combatants, the latter of whom should receive immunity from violent actions.
Since the Just War criteria are well-documented, the above is but an extremely brief outline. Many of these criteria have been adopted by non-religious ethical codes such as the Geneva Convention.
Importantly, these criteria are reasonable, even intuitive, to many readers today. In principle, the Just War criteria are sensible and widely-agreed-upon. In practice, however, we creative human beings often create less-than-fully-warranted justifications and rationalisations for our actions. We all experience this on an individual basis; it is also the case at the societal or international level.
Fundamentally, Scripture affirms that we human beings have a penchant for self-vindication and self-delusion. Add into the mix notions of urgency, uncertainty, pragmatism, or realpolitik… and it becomes all too easy to apply self-justifications to Just War criteria. Our self-serving human nature can easily render the whole exercise rather less-than-just. The criteria are just; we humans are not.
Further, even with just criteria, can war itself ever be described as good and righteous? Yes, war may be necessary as a last resort, in defence of a vulnerable neighbour. But even in such situations, can war itself be properly dubbed “a greater good” or even a “good”?
It is well-known that combatants, even those on the “winning” side, may suffer from post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). The related concept of moral injury, the harm to one’s soul and psyche arising from witnessing or participating in transgressions of one’s conscience or internal moral compass, likewise applies.
Non-combatants also suffer. Loved ones become killed or maimed. Life-sustaining necessities like food, water, medicines, electricity become increasingly unavailable. Farms and factories, roads and real estate are destroyed, and along with them, entire livelihoods. Even when war is necessary, these inevitable corollaries of war cannot be considered “good”.
To describe war as “good” is perhaps an under-realised eschatology, an emphasis on the Now at the expense of the Not-Yet, an inadequate recognition that the Kingdom of God has already broken into our present broken world. Peace, not war, is God’s ideal that will come in fullness in the New Creation.
War is perhaps as “good” as divorce is “good”, that is, allowed by God in a fallen human world, but in no way part of God’s ideal (Matthew 19.4-8). Neither divorce nor war are quite worthy of the label “good”.
The Evil of War
“I know war as few other men now living know it, and nothing to me is more revolting. I have long advocated its complete abolition, as its very destructiveness on both friend and foe has rendered it useless as a means of settling international disputes. … But once war is forced upon us, there is no other alternative than to apply every available means to bring it to a swift end.” – General Douglas MacArthur
War is not a good. War is evil, an activity which shows forth evil in lives lost, evil in livelihoods destroyed, evil in a society’s way of life disrupted.
These evils occur even when the just war criteria are met.
These evils get thrust upon a community, even if pacifist individuals refuse to take up arms in participation.
These evils are experienced alike by belligerent, defender, and non-combatant.
War, being evil, cannot then be described as a “greater good”. But war is sometimes a lesser evil. War is sometimes the least bad option among many bad options.
War, Peace, Lament
Too long have I had my dwelling among those who hate peace. I am for peace; but when I speak, they are for war. – Psalm 120.6-7
Even if we are forced into armed conflict, can we Christians do so thumping our chests, full of bloodlust? Even if we have no other option than war, can we followers of the Prince of Peace invoke divine favour over the destruction of other human combatants?
Even if we go to war for just reasons, even if we are certain that war is the least bad option among a suite of even worse options – still, we must lament the act of war.
To lament is not simply to mourn or to complain. Lament is directing our sorrows and complaints to somebody – to God. Lament is directed unto Jesus, for whom pain and suffering and evil are not mere concepts or emotions, but lived experience. Our laments are directed to the Man of Sorrows, the Suffering Servant, the Coming King.
And so, in Christ and to Christ, we lament. Even if we participate in warfare as the least evil option available to us, we do so in lament. We lament the loss of life, the loss of livelihood. We lament the underlying brokenness that led to the outbreak of hostilities. We lament the human causes and costs of war.
War is evil. Yet it is not an absolute or irredeemable evil. For even amidst horrendous evils, God is not absent. The evils of war are not beyond the pale of God’s salvation and redemption. With neither under- nor over-realised eschatology, we look to the sovereign Ruler of this Now-and-Not-Yet Kingdom. We bring our laments before the King who entered into human brokenness, who is at work in the very midst of brokenness.
In so doing, these our laments become more than expressions of pain or grief or loss. Directed unto God, they become also expressions of faith and hope and longing for that coming day when brokenness will be no more, when the Lord will rule justly, and when the swords will be beaten into plowshares before the slain and risen Lamb. Maranatha, Lord Jesus!
The views in this article are entirely the author’s own and do not represent the official position of the Trinity Annual Conference or the Methodist Church in Singapore.
Rev Gilbert Lok has undergraduate training in Economics (1st-class honours, NUS), and postgraduate degrees in Divinity (TTC) and New Testament (Oxford). Formerly a civil servant, Gilbert now serves as a pastor at Barker Road Methodist Church.
















